Christians have not always agreed on the nature, duration, and purpose of hell. The table below offers a brief comparison of five major views and is based on lecture notes by Dr. Rick Griffith.
| View | Universalism | Annihilationism | Purgatory | Metaphorical | Literal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who's Saved? | All | Some | Some | Some | Some |
| Who's Tormented? | Some (old view), None (new view) | Some | Some | Some | Some |
| Literal, Bodily Suffering? | Yes (old view), No (new view) | Yes | Yes (but some say metaphorical) | No | Yes |
| Salvation After Suffering? | Yes (old view), N/A (new view) | No | Possible | No | No |
| Purpose of Suffering? | Redemption | Punishment | Redemption | Punishment | Punishment |
| State Fixed at Death? | No (old view), Yes (new view) | Yes | No for those with venial sins | Yes | Yes |
| Hell Eternal? | No (it's non-existent) | No (it's temporal) | ? | Yes | Yes |
| Soul Eternal? | Yes | Believers only | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Theological Persuasion | Liberals & Mormons | Anglicans, Jehovah's Witnesses, Seventh-day Adventists, & "Evangelicals" | Catholics & Eastern Orthodox | Evangelicals & Moderates | Evangelicals Only |
| Advocates | Wm. Barclay, Karl Barth, G. B. Caird, John Hick, John Robinson | Clark Pinnock, Basil Atkinson, F. F. Bruce, LeRoy E. Froom, Edward Fudge, H. Guillebaud, Philip Hughes, John R. W. Stott, John Wenham | Z. Hayes, Augustine, Thomas Aquinas, Gregory the Great, L. Berkhof, C. Pinnock | Wm. Crockett, C. S. Lewis, John Calvin, D. A. Carson, M. Erickson, Billy Graham, Donald Guthrie, K. Kantzer, Leon Morris, J. I. Packer, R. A. Peterson, Herman Hoyt | J. F. Walvoord, J. Ankerburg, L. Boettner, Harry Buis, John Gerstner, R. Griffith, W. Grudem, R. Gundry, Murray Harris, W. Hendriksen, A. Hoekema, William Lane, Robert Morey, Arthur Pink, W. T. G. Shedd |
FreeRequest: Matthew 24:4–31 — Chronology in Dispensationalism
The chronological view of more than 60 dispensational authors on Matthew 24 — request it by email below.
Enter your email and we will send the PDF as an attachment. See our privacy policy.
Author
Leonardo A. Costa
A researcher and writer exploring dispensationalism from a progressive perspective, with a deep appreciation for the tradition's heritage.
Related Articles
The Canonical Reading Layer: A Hermeneutical Double Standard in Traditional Dispensationalism
The thousand-year millennium is not in the Old Testament — it comes from Revelation 20. Traditional Dispensationalism reads it back into Isaiah, Ezekiel, and Zechariah by canonical complementation, yet rejects the same hermeneutical move when Progressive Dispensationalism applies New Covenant blessings to Gentiles. Exposing the double standard from a premillennial perspective.
The Mark of the Beast and 666
A book-length biblical study arguing that the mark of the Beast is a future mark tied to the Antichrist, not present-day technologies.
Peter's Use of Joel 2 in Acts 2 in Dispensationalism: Analogy or Partial Fulfillment?
A survey showing that many traditional dispensationalists affirm the same partial/inaugurated fulfillment of Joel 2 in Acts 2 that progressive dispensationalists do—they simply use different vocabulary.
Comparative Millennial Views
Four millennial views—Dispensational Premillennialism, Historic Premillennialism, Amillennialism, Postmillennialism—compared on eighteen topics; same summaries as the interactive tool, in printable sections with four cards each.